Having sailed with Windstar three times over the last few years, twice on a Star Class ship and also on the Wind Spirit this article will reflect on the differences between sailing on Windstar’s tall ships and the newer Star class ships. 

Let’s start with the one thing that we found to run through the DNA of both classes of ship, the amazing crew. With the exception of the larger Wind Surf, the Wind class ships are much smaller than the Star class ships with 148 passenger capacity compared to 342 in the Star class ships, but the level of service and friendliness of the crew is the same on all of their ships, with signature events such as the deck BBQ, crew line dancing and talent show taking place throughout the fleet.

Even though the Wind class ships are smaller than the Star class ships the variety and quality of dining on offer is very similar with the Amphora main dining room on all ships having a similar feel and menu to each other. Although the buffet style Veranda restaurant is smaller on the Wind class ships the options are as varied as the larger ships, with both venues offering al fresco dining and reverting to Candles in the evening, with exactly the same menu on all ships. Both classes of ship also offer the wonderful Yacht Club cafe venue with barista prepared coffee and delicious snacks always on offer. However, the Star class ships offer two other dining venues not available on the Wind class ship, The Star Grill BBQ-focused venue headed up by renowned chef, Steven Raichlen, and the innovative Cuadro 44, a Spanish tapas style restaurant with a menu created by Anthony Sasso. With Windstar’s collaboration with the James Beard Foundation, no matter which class of ship you sail on you can be assured that the menus and food on offer are always top notch. 

The biggest difference in the two classes of ship can be seen in the accommodation on offer. With the Star class ships offering ‘All Suite’ luxurious accommodation there is no denying that your stay in one of the larger Star class ships with be much more comfortable than it will be on one of the Wind class ships, where there is no option to have a balcony. All of the staterooms on the Wind class ships are almost exactly the same, offering porthole views from the 18 square metre staterooms, compared to the 26 square metres available in most of the Star class suites, some with large ocean view windows and some with French balconies. The Star class ships also offer more variety of suites with the choice of nine Owners Suites ranging from 43.5 square metres to 76 square metres compared to the lone Owners Suite on the Wind class ships measuring a mere 21 square metres. Although the staterooms on the Wind class ships are reasonably well appointed and comfortable enough, they simply can’t offer the same level of luxury and modernity of those in the Star class ships. 

However, sailing on a Wind class ship offers such a unique experience you simply won’t want to spend much time in your stateroom. With their magnificent triangular sailing masts deployed whenever possible and the engines shut down if possible, so the ship can sail under the power of the wind, you won’t want to be anywhere else except on the open decks. Having had a whole new section of ship inserted into the middle of its body, the Star class ships now have a larger pool deck with two whirlpools and a larger infinity style pool, but this isn’t to say that the pool deck on the Wind class ships is any less inviting. Having less passengers on board, the small splash pool and one whirlpool is perfectly adequate and there are plenty of sunbeds and tables available to make this a very sociable place to pass the day, especially with the wonderful pool bar on hand to serve refreshing cocktails. 

While both types of ships regularly perform the signature 1492 Conquest of Paradise sailaway ceremony, the rousing music playing in the background as the sails unfurl just seems to reach emotions that merely raising a flag on an engine powered ship simply can’t. Our one sailing on the Wind Spirit was a week long voyage around the Society Islands in French Polynesia and with the combination of this incredible place and the beautiful tall ship we can honestly say that this was the most romantic cruise we have ever taken. 

We always love sailing on a Windstar ship, loving the homeliness of all areas of the ship, the friendliness of the crew and the level of relaxation that we seem to achieve whenever we’re on board. While we wouldn’t have sailed through Tahiti on any other ship, absolutely adoring the romance of being on a tall ship, there’s no denying that the Star class ships offer more luxury and choice than the smaller ships can ever offer. But in all honesty, with the amazing crew, the intimate and homely vibe and the unusual itineraries we wouldn’t hesitate to sail on any the the Windstar ships, always feeling like we are on a home away from home. 

If you would like to make an enquiry about a cruise on Windstar, or any other cruise line, simply click here and someone will be in touch with you soon.


Thank you to our preferred travel partners Panache cruises and Windstar Cruises who hosted us on all of these cruises. Please note that neither Windstar cruises or Panache had any editorial control over any of our content, either before, during our after our voyage and all other costs (excluding the cruise fare) were covered by ourselves.

If you enjoyed this blog why not take a look at these other Windstar blogs, our Star Plus Dining Guide or the Star Legend Ship tour . For more information on sailing French Polynesia with Windstar read our Tahiti blog and review and to see video reviews of our Windstar experiences then visit our Windstar playlist on YouTube

If you are interested in booking a cruise with these or any other luxury cruise lines then we would recommend contacting a connoisseur at our trusted cruise partners Panache cruises - please mention that you have been referred to them through Visit With Us.

If you would like to receive notification of any new blog posts, updates of our travels or links to our vlogs we would love for you to sign up to our mail list below. Thank you.